I've been searching a very long time to find a leather winter boot fully line with real sheep wool and in my size (a 12!). When I saw this on Amazon, I was quite skeptical because of the affordable price. Too, I was a bit concerned with the few negative reviews about the boot coming apart.
HOWEVER ... every one has sung the praises of Bearpaw's excellent customer service so I felt it was a safe risk.
I've only worn them a half a dozen times but just LOVE them. They are very comfortable and keep my feet very warm in our frigid Michigan winter.
I also did purchase UGG's cleaning and care kit to treat the leather and maintain them.

I have been looking for this boot in black at an affordable price for 2 years and finally found it on Amazon. TMI warning. I have bilateral primary lymphedema of the lower extremities translated means I have chronic severe swelling of both of my legs above the ankle and below the calf which makes buying winter boots almost impossible. I found a pair of Bearpaws in a green at a store locally which doesn't match anything I own and green isn't a color I want to wear but I needed a boot that I could get on that would keep me warm and dry and could accomodate the swelling with or without the toggle button fastened. The green pair worked but they've seen better days. I had been looking for them in Black for 2 years but I couldn't afford them until I searched Amazon this year. I didn't even have to think about it I ordered them they've arrived and I'll be ready for whatever winter throws at me this year.