I scepticlly ordered these boots, I was just looking for something that was closed toed for the winter months. And I have to say,I love these boots! I read the reviews and ordered a larger size then normal. I'm normaly an 8 or 81/2 depending on the style and I have some what wide feet. I ordered a 9 and they fit great. I can wear them with one pair of thicker socks. If I lived where it was really cold and needed multiple layers of socks then I would likely need a bigger size, or deal with a tight fit. They are super cute. I gave them a 4star rating just because they aren't super cozy inside. They did not hurt my feet by any means, but they could maybe use some insoles to add comfort. I plan on buying another pair in a different color